It Is Finished

Brett Crull · April 18, 2025

Using the two thieves crucified with Jesus, the sermon describes three ways bitterness enters the soul: anger at God, not feeling forgiven for sins already confessed, and refusing to forgive others. It argues that God does not want believers to carry bitterness and invites honest prayer, confession, and forgiveness, including prayer with another person. The preacher shares healing-prayer stories and a personal testimony of reconciliation.

Isaiah 52:13-53:12, John 19:1-37

Preached on Luke 23:32-43 · 2 Corinthians 5

Books of the Bible:IsaiahLukeJohn2 Corinthians

Download
Sermon series Holy Week 2025

Transcript

Search it, or tap a time to listen from there.

The Bible gives us the framework and language of two ways. There's the way of righteousness and the way of wickedness, the way of wisdom and the way of folly, the way of light and the way of darkness, the way of life and the way of death. And there is a great difference between these two ways.

The Gospels tell us that Jesus was crucified between two criminals. Matthew and Mark's Gospels tell us that these criminals were thieves. They also tell us that both thieves joined in the keeping of abuse and scorn upon Jesus as he was crucified. But Luke's Gospel tells us something that Matthew and Mark leave out.

One of these two thieves repented and received salvation. Six hours is a long time to hang upon a cross. And at some point before the end, something happened that changed the heart of one of those thieves. And he found joy and peace while the other died in bitterness.

And so the two thieves are another example of two ways. The choice that is constantly before you and me, which way to choose. Who are you and who are you becoming? As I've been praying and preparing for tonight, I have a growing confidence that the Lord is going to move to bring healing and freedom for many who are suffering from a bitterness of soul.

So many Christians live without joy. They live without freedom, wondering, is this really the reward for following Jesus? Perhaps they console themselves by saying, well, I guess this is just the way it's supposed to be. After all, it is a fallen, broken world. There is suffering in this life. And they genuinely ask, can I expect more? Am I allowed to more? Is it even right to desire joy, freedom, and peace in my soul? It seems selfish, maybe.

And the result is that many Christians live out their lives carrying a burden of bitterness in their soul that robs them of joy. It's true that the Bible promises there will be suffering in this life. The Bible teaches us that it is through many tribulations we enter the kingdom of God. But is this the kind of suffering that is meant?

Are we meant to carry a burden of bitterness and joylessness as part of the suffering of this life? I say no. No. There are other sufferings and trials that the Lord intends for you as part of your growth and discipline to become like Him, to become holy. But the burden of bitterness is not such a one.

The Lord does not want you to carry bitterness in your soul. He wants you to be set free. Perhaps tonight will be a night of freedom from bitterness for you and for many. Tonight through the story of the two thieves, we're going to look at three sources of bitterness, how bitterness comes into our soul. First, how bitterness enters through our anger at God. Second, how bitterness enters through not feeling forgiven for sins we've confessed. And third, how bitterness enters the soul through not forgiving others.

And I'm going to be teaching from Luke's gospel account of the passion. There were two others who were criminals who were led away to be put to death with Him. And when they came to the place that is called the skull, there they crucified Him and the criminals, one on His right and one on His left.

And Jesus said, Father, forgive them, for they know not what they do. And they cast lots to divide His garments. And the people stood by watching, but the rulers scoffed at Him, saying, He saved others. Let Him save Himself, if He is the Christ of God, His chosen one. The soldiers also mocked Him, coming up and offering Him sour wine and saying, if you are the King of the Jews, save yourself.

There was also an inscription over Him, this is the King of the Jews. One of the criminals who were hanged railed at Him, saying, are you not the Christ? Save yourself and us. But the other rebuked Him, saying, do you not fear God, since you are under the same sentence of condemnation, and we indeed justly, for we are receiving the due reward of our deeds. But this man has done nothing wrong.

And he said, Jesus, remember me when you come into your kingdom. And Jesus said to him, truly, I say to you, today you will be with me in paradise. Bitterness enters the soul when we are angry at God. Here, again, what one of the criminals said, are you not the Christ? Save yourself and us. Consider his situation, humiliated and suffering great physical pain, and knowing that he was soon to die. He saw God nearby, apparently doing nothing. And that made him angry.

And his anger made him blind. He said, why don't you do something? Why don't you save us when that was precisely what Jesus was doing? But he couldn't see that. The repentant thief saw. Jesus, remember me when you come into your kingdom. Oh, the faith of that repentant thief to see in a mangled, dying man the hope of the world. The king and lord of all, who at that very moment and in this very act was bringing his kingdom and his salvation. The repentant thief saw it. The bitter thief could not see God at work, even doing the very thing he demanded of him.

Save us. And Jesus could have said, I am. The same is true of us. Our anger at God and our bitterness keeps us from seeing how God is at work, always doing the very thing we need most, sometimes even doing the thing we demand of him, though we cannot see it.

I read somewhere recently that most Christians struggle emotionally because they are angry with God, but they won't admit it. Consider how you sometimes respond like the bitter thief. Humiliation comes or pain. You look and God apparently is doing nothing. And bitterness sets in.

Are you not God? Why aren't you doing anything? Now would be a great time to change my situation. So I ask you tonight, where are you angry at God? Where is their pain? Where is their humiliation and God's perceived inaction? When we reflect on the moments of greatest pain in our lives, so often the question is,

God, where were you and why did you let that happen to me? So often that's the question. And the why part of that question, why did you let this happen? God rarely, if ever, answers that. But the where question, God, where were you? He always answers that part of the question.

I was there and I was loving you with an everlasting love and if you let me, I will show you. Through healing prayer, we can imaginatively return to a painful memory and look for Jesus. And when we see Him or when we hear His voice, our soul is healed. And the wound from that painful memory is healed and the pain leaves.

There's a story from Francis and Judith McNutt and their healing ministry in Jacksonville that they tell of a pastor from Asia who had a successful ministry and loved the Lord and yet dealt with a sexual addiction that he could not break no matter what he did. And so this man flew halfway around the world to Jacksonville to receive a day of prayer.

And so as they entered into prayer, those praying for him, they discerned, we don't think that your sexual addiction is primarily about lust. We wonder if there's a wound earlier in your life in which the devil exploited you in a vulnerable time. Tell us about your childhood. And he said, well, my father abandoned us. I never knew him. And my mother neglected me often. And as they began to pray, the Holy Spirit revealed a specific memory in which this pastor, when he was three years old, his mother placed him outside in the backyard in a little kiddie pool to occupy him so she could go and do something else. And as that three-year-old boy, as he sat there in the pool,

time went on and the water became cold. And it began to be dark. And he was afraid and crying, crying for his mother. And she did not come. So they invited him to look for Jesus. And he saw Jesus come into that memory. And when Jesus came, there was light in the darkness. And Jesus placed his two hands into the pool and the water became warm. And then he looked and he saw Mary.

And he saw Jesus pick him up, dry him off, and place him in the arms of Mary. And in that moment, he knew, Jesus, you were there. And that's what your love for me was speaking to me, though I couldn't access it at the time, now I can. And that man went back home healed of his sexual addiction.

If you are angry at God, it's because there is a wound in your soul, but that is a wound that Jesus wants to heal, and he can. It's not great to be angry at God. But the one thing worse than being angry at God is being angry at God and pretending that you're not. Denying it, ignoring it. Maybe because you're ashamed. Christians aren't supposed to be angry at God. Or you just wonder, what's the point? He is God. I can't do anything about this. So what do you do with your anger at God? The last thing you'd expect. Tell God why you're angry at him. He's a big boy. He can handle it. He invites your honesty.

Because somewhere in the vicinity of your anger at God, there is a deep, unmet need, or a shattering disappointment. There is a wound. And the value of telling him why you're angry, and telling him about it, is that helps you locate where is that wound.

And once you've reached that point of total honesty with the Lord, and you've located that wound, now he can go at work to set you free from the bitterness. He can go at work to meet that deep, unmet need. To bring comfort to that shattering disappointment. So when you've reached that point of total honesty, you've told him why you're angry.

That is sacred time with the Lord. And that is time, then, yes, tell him you're sorry. Lord, I'm sorry that I've been angry. I'm sorry for my bitterness. I'm sorry that I haven't trusted you. But then invite him into that place, that wound. Invite him to meet that deep, unmet need. To bring comfort to the disappointment, and to open your eyes to see what the bitter thief could not. How Jesus is and was at work, doing for you the thing you needed most.

That is how we've come free from the bitterness that enters our soul through anger at God. Let's now turn and consider the other thief. The good thief told the other thief, don't you realize that we are under the sentence of condemnation? And we indeed justly. For we are receiving the due reward of our deeds.

No one can be a Christian who does not know in his or her bones these words apply to me. To me also. I too am under the sentence of condemnation, and but for the mercy of God and the grace given to me through the cross of Jesus Christ, that is also my fate.

There's a famous story about G.K. Chesterton that a newspaper sent out an inquiry inviting people to write in the answer to the question, what is wrong with the world? And Chesterton writes an essay essentially saying, I am. And until every man understands, I am wrong. Any notions about how to fix the world, it's just a hobby of idealism.

In the name of God, let me invite you to the joy of confession. If you are hiding anything from God or from the church, bring it into the light. Bring all of it into the light and be free. The love and grace of God will enfold you. So in researching for this sermon, I came across another sermon by this gentle, benevolent, so kindly seeming heretical bishop

of the Episcopal Church, John Shelby Spong. And the title of his sermon was, The Cross Was Jesus' Glory, He Did Not Die for Your Sins. That was the title of the sermon. And the point of his sermon was to extol the example of total self-giving love that was on the cross. And there was almost nothing that we would disagree with in what he said positively. He spoke beautifully about self-giving love. It's what he left out that we would say, that's not the whole picture. The cross is also the place where Jesus took on our sins. And as the apostle Paul says in 2 Corinthians 5, he became sin like the animal sacrifices of old. And he gave his blood as a ransom, the payment for our sin. He paid a debt he did not owe because we owed a debt we could not pay. So there are some versions of Christianity represented by Bishop Spong

that feel that talking about sin and asking people to confess makes them feel bad. And we should avoid making people feel bad. And instead, we should focus rather on the abundant life that Jesus came to give. Well, that's like a doctor refusing to tell someone that they're dying of a disease that's curable simply because it's not nice to tell somebody they have a disease. And of course, if you're the patient, you're thinking, tell me of my disease, then give me the cure. The dying thief knew well the disease. He rejoiced to learn also of the cure.

We indeed justly are receiving the due reward of our deeds. But this man has done nothing wrong. And then he said to Jesus, Jesus, remember me when you come into your kingdom. And Jesus said to him, So what happened for the repentant thief? Because earlier we said Mark in Matthew's Gospel say that he also abused Jesus and heaped scorn upon him. Well, Father Stephen has a theory about this that I think has a lot of credibility to it. Six hours is a long time to hang up there on a cross.

Something happened. And Father Stephen believes that those two narratives are compatible, that at the beginning both thieves did in fact heap abuse and scorn on Jesus, but one of them changed. Why? Because he saw how Jesus responded to the abuse and the scorn. And especially, he saw Jesus forgive those who were killing him. Only Luke includes the story of the repentant thief. Likewise, only Luke includes the part where Jesus forgives his executioners. Perhaps it is because those two moments are linked. The repentant thief became the repentant thief when he witnessed Jesus forgiving his enemies. He saw what real love looks like. And in that moment, he knew he had been wrong. Here is the true Messiah. But there's more. In that moment, he also understood that he too was forgiven for joining in the mocking and the abuse. And as he hung there, he began to think, if I can be forgiven for mocking God, then I

can be forgiven for the crimes that put me on this cross. And if I can be forgiven of the crimes that put me on this cross, I can be forgiven for everything that I have done. Every wrong. And knowing this, he turned to Jesus and he said, remember me. Which is another way of saying, forgive me. And Jesus said, today you'll be with me, which is another way of saying, I forgive you.

And he lived out his final hours in peace and hope. Even as his legs were being broken, he knew it's only a matter of time, a few more moments, I will see him again, alive. But often that is not our experience. And it's for one reason or another, we do not feel the hope and the peace that is meant to accompany repentance.

And bitterness enters our soul because we do not feel forgiven. There are many reasons for this. But if you discern that there is a bitterness in your soul because there are sins you've confessed but you don't feel forgiven, then like with anger at God, the way to begin dealing with that is tell Jesus about it. So when you come to the cross tonight, tell him where you don't feel forgiven. But I also encourage you, tell someone who can pray for you tonight.

As I said, there are many reasons. But the most common one for sins we've confessed but we don't feel forgiven is we just imagine this one is too big. It's just too big. We've confessed, but deep down we really question, am I forgiven?

And when sins of the past bring continual regret into the present, or when you find yourself saying things like, I just can't believe that I did that, sometimes it may be helpful for you to know the power of forgiving yourself. Did you know you could do that? It's the same idea or another way of receiving God's forgiveness. It's the same thing, but put in different language. And sometimes the changing of that language to say, God, I forgive myself for that thing I can't believe I did, helps us to enter into the receiving of that forgiveness. It's also possible that you may need help in the ministry of a brother or a sister in Christ in order to be set free.

This was the case for me. And part of my testimony, as some of you have heard, but it's my testimony and I love to share it, is that many years ago as a young man before I met Julie, I was in a relationship with a young woman.

And as too often happens, even though we were both Christians, at some point we drifted into sexual sin. And I justified and I rationalized and yet deep down knew that it was wrong and I shoved that feeling away. I even received a phone call the week that we drifted into sexual sin. I received a phone call from a man I had known for one week, five years prior to that moment. We had ministered together at a camp up in the mountains. He called me and he said, Brett, I've had dreams with you and I have a message for you from God. But first I want to ask you a question. Are you in a relationship right now? I said, as a matter of fact, I am.

And he said, I have another question. Have you done anything physically that you shouldn't have? This is the week that we had. Do you want to know what I told him? I said, no. And I didn't think I was lying to him. I was so deceived.

And he went on to say, well, I feel that I have a warning for you to watch out for sexual sin. And I hung up and I said, that was strange. Can you believe that I did that? People say, oh, that God would tell me clearly what to do. And he did. And I still ignored it because the reality is he had already told me in his word. And if his word wasn't clear enough for me, even a prophet from five years out of my past giving me a prophetic dream was not enough to turn me from my way. Thanks be to God, that relationship ended. And when it did, I became clear eyed and was able to see many things. I remembered that phone call and I knew my sin and I knew I had betrayed God.

And I was studying the Bible and I was going to be a pastor and I knew I had blown it and there was no forgiveness for me. And I told a friend, I feel like a bug wrapped in a spider's web and I'm just waiting for a spider to come and end my life because I've screwed up so badly. That same week, somebody invited me to a prayer meeting where they were practicing prophetic and listening prayer. And as I was receiving prayer, the woman praying for me said, Brett, I see your heart and it's encased in a cobweb. And I knew that's exactly where I am. And she said, now I see the finger of God moving toward your heart. And I thought, to smite my wicked heart. Instead, she said, I see the finger of God gently rubbing the outside of your heart and removing the cobweb. And I knew that I was forgiven.

Even of what I had done, I was forgiven. Finally, a main entry point for bitterness in our soul comes when we do not forgive those who've sinned against us. We've been saying all along that the source in the beginning of the repentant thief's conversion was witnessing Jesus forgive his enemies. This was his turning point, a powerful thing to behold. The cross makes possible obedience to the command that we love and forgive our enemies. Without the cross, this is impossible.

But listen again. Jesus said, Father, forgive them for they know not what they do. Last night, we were given the new commandment, love one another as I have loved you. No longer is the standard love your neighbor as you love yourself. The standard is now love one another with my love. And here we see that difference most clearly demonstrated. The cross alone makes this kind of love possible. The love of Jesus alone makes it possible to forgive our enemies. Well, the prayer with the cobweb is only part of the story. There's another part to the story. That relationship ended because she realized that she was still in love with the other guy that she had dated the year before. And so I hated him. And I know what Jesus meant when he said, if you hate, it is murder. Because I would have killed him if I could have. And even after I'd been healed by receiving forgiveness for my wrongs, and even after

I'd come to see that it was a good thing that that relationship had ended, still there was a bitterness in my soul that I could not get rid of. And it just so happened that at that time, I was hired to play trumpet at the Saturday Night Vigil for Church of the Resurrection, where I was not attending at the time.

This was 20 years ago this Holy Week, by the way. 20 years ago this Holy Week. And it also happened to be the case that the other guy was on music team also. So I called John Fawcett, I explained the situation, I said, I'm so sorry that you'll need to find a new trumpet player six days away. And John very graciously says, well, I understand. At the same time, church is the one place in the world where you can be with someone who has hurt you profoundly.

I encourage you to be reconciled. I took that as counsel from the Lord, and she and I spoke, and we shared the ways we had hurt one another, we admitted those wrongs, we forgave one another, and we left as brother and sister in Christ. Then I went to him, and we talked, and he said, man, there was a time long ago when I hated your guts. And I said, man, there was a time not so long ago when I hated your guts.

We confessed our mutual hatred, we even laughed. This is crazy. Why are we doing this? And we knew only because of the cross of Jesus Christ we forgave one another, and we left as friends and brothers. That Saturday night, at the exchange of peace, the three of us made sure to find one another, and that was the most meaningful exchange of peace I've ever experienced. Not every situation can be resolved with reconciliation face to face, but in every case, you can forgive someone before God in prayer. Pastor and minister Marcus Warner says, we don't forgive because people deserve it. We forgive to set ourselves free from the bondage produced by bitterness.

And a lot can be said about extending forgiveness, but for the sake of time, I'll be very simple. Jesus commands us to forgive every sin done against us. There's no exceptions. And there's no freedom until we do. But what he commands, he also makes possible. You can choose to forgive even when you feel you don't want to. You say, Jesus, I choose to forgive, and you name the person for, and you say the thing they did to you. Forgiveness is a miracle every time. It is humanly impossible. But if you choose to say yes to forgiveness, you will feel the strength of Jesus within you who is still speaking from the cross and saying, Father, forgive.

So tonight, do you need to be set free from bitterness in your soul? Has bitterness entered your soul through anger at God or through feeling that you are not forgiven or from failing to forgive others? Tonight when you go to the cross, tell Jesus about it. But I also encourage you here tonight, tell another person too, and let them pray for you.

Jesus, remember us, each one of us, when you come into your kingdom. Amen.

Sermon series

Holy Week 2025

5 sermons

View series
  1. A King Worth Following
    Will Chester Part 1

    Isaiah 52:13-15, Luke 19:29-40

  2. Christ Our Passover
    Stewart Ruch Part 2

    Exodus 12:1-14, Psalm 78:15-26, Luke 22:14-30

  3. It Is FinishedNow viewing
    Brett Crull Part 3

    Isaiah 52:13-53:12, John 19:1-37

  4. There Will be Dancing
    Matt Woodley Part 5

    Acts 10:34-43, Luke 24:1-12

Listen anywhere

Every Sunday sermon goes into our podcast feed. Subscribe and new ones arrive on their own.