Transcript
Search it, or tap a time to listen from there.
On a June evening at a historic black church in Charleston, South Carolina, 2015, several members of a church called Mother Emanuel had gathered to do what they did every week, which was to have Bible study. A young white man that they didn't know showed up at the Bible study and he asked if he could join them, and they graciously, of course, welcomed him in. They were delighted he could be a part of their Bible study that evening.
As many of you know from the account, an hour into the Bible study, Dylann Roof took out a gun and shot and killed nine of the members of that Bible study. Soon afterwards, he made clear that he had done so with the hope of starting a race riot.
He self-described as a white supremacist. He had every intent of catalyzing a race riot through Charleston, and he had hoped through the rest of the country. But that June evening, Dylann Roof miscalculated. He didn't understand that within a matter of two days, what he would catalyze would not be a race riot, but a stunning movement
of, by the world's standards, inexplicable Christian forgiveness being poured out upon him. Five members of different families who had lost a family member in that evil shooting asked to speak to Dylann Roof in his first hearing two days after the murders. Nadine Collier said this to Dylann, her mother's murderer, I just want everybody to know, to
you, I forgive you. You took something very precious away from me. I will never be able to talk to her again. I will never be able to hold her again. You hurt me. But God forgives you and I forgive you. Stunning, right? Beyond controversy, right?
Wrong. And you can pull that slide for the moment. No, not beyond controversy. As a matter of fact, Nadine's statement and the statements that were made received a great deal of pushback in social media and in the press. As a matter of fact, statements were made regarding Collier's statement and other statements like Collier's, not in just in this incident, but in many incidents
where Christians and others have chosen to proclaim forgiveness in the midst of unspeakable tragedy. There's a kind of no forgiveness movement that responded to Collier's statement. They made very clear to forgive someone like Dylann Roof is absolutely morally inappropriate. And before you quickly dismiss this no forgiveness stance, it's worth asking, why would people respond that way to a statement like Nadine's? And in summary, I would argue that this no forgiveness stance, this no forgiveness movement insists that the sin that was done in this case by Dylann Roof is gravely serious.
And simple words spoken like I forgive you, from the perspective of these folks in no forgiveness, those words are perversely misguided empathy or sympathy, and it is utterly inappropriate. The position that they hold cries out, wait, you can't just say this. There's got to be justice. Someone must pay for the deaths of these innocents. If you forgive evil, the movement goes on, or injustice or abuse, you will only give the sinner, the murderer, a free pass to sin again. Indeed, this no forgiveness movement might even quote from the 11th century Archbishop of Canterbury, Anselm, who argued that if you imagine forgiveness to be simple, you have, quote, not yet considered the heavy weight that sin is.
So let's look at this honestly and say, we can see the point that I'm in a no forgiveness movement. We could make, we could understand that we would have to understand the roots of Christian forgiveness. We have to understand the formation and training and discipleship that someone like Nadine had given herself to. You could absolutely understand why you would say you're just saying that in the wake of that. Indeed, this position of no forgiveness gets one side of an equation right, but it is lacking the full equation of the kingdom of God. It lacks the full equation of the gospel of Jesus Christ, and therefore it cannot come to the right solution. It gets the right side of the equation correct that they understand in some measure the gravity, the profundity, the utter destruction of sin. And for that, we would say as biblical Christians, yes, we agree with the profound reality of sin. But in that position, you have sin plus us, sin plus our voice, sin plus our protest,
sin plus our desire to bring justice in some way. When you get sin plus us, here's what you equal, sinful us. Sin plus us just equals more and more of sinful us. You can actually multiply that to switch mathematical types to a kind of exponential terror. Sin plus us just equals more and more of sinful us. Violence begetting violence. Terror begetting
terror. Alan Jacobs, one time professor at Wheaton College, public intellectual, has this quote. When a society rejects the Christian of count of who we are, it doesn't become less moralistic, but far more so because it retains an underdeveloped sense of justice, but has no means of offering or receiving forgiveness.
That's worth like a whole lecture. I'm not going to do that tonight, but I did ask Addie to put that up so you can see it. I want to read it one more time because it's important. When a society rejects the Christian account of who we are, Christian identity based in the cross of Jesus Christ that we're looking at tonight, it doesn't become less moralistic, but far more so because it retains an underdeveloped sense of justice, but has no means of offering or receiving forgiveness. You can pull that quote now, Addie. Can you imagine a society
or a community or family where there is no means of offering or receiving forgiveness? It's important to understand what that means for a society, but it's more important that we understand that while we may live in a society that has aspects that is like that, we ultimately live in a kingdom that operates in the exact opposite way.
In the kingdom of God, in the kingdom of Jesus, in the kingdom of the cross of Jesus Christ, we actually live in a place, in a kingdom that has this equation. Sin, same as the beginning equation, plus the cross equals forgiveness. What had Nadine learned? What had been formed in her? What had been taught in her? What Bible verses had she memorized? What other Bible studies had she gone to? How would she take in Isaiah chapter 53 seriously in her life and actually incorporated it, not just in her thinking, but in her actions? What had happened in that woman? So when the moment of testing came, an ultimate moment of testing, where she loses her own mother, she says, you hurt me. She doesn't deny what happened. She doesn't candy coat what happened. She names the brutality of what happened. I'll never be able to hold her again. But God forgives you. That comes first.
And I forgive you. I don't know much about Nadine, but I can tell you that we're in the presence of a theologian who understands the cross of Jesus Christ. Family of God, tonight I want to proclaim to you out of Isaiah 53 that with his wounds, by his cross, we are healed. We are forgiven. And we are empowered to extend forgiveness and receive forgiveness for our sins. With his wounds, we are healed. Forgiveness is a sacrament of the cross. Forgiveness is a concrete expression, a concrete application of the cross of Jesus Christ. If you see that cross, if you hear that story and you wonder, how can I get in that story? How can I access that story? How can I live in my own embodied way within the story of the cross? I don't want to feel removed from it. I want to be connected to it. I want to have my life bonded to it.
Then the way in is forgiveness. That's how you concretely live the cross of Jesus Christ. All right, turn with me to page 614 in your Bibles there, your sanctuary Bibles, or if you have brought your Bible with you, go to Isaiah 53. Isaiah 53 comes from the prophet Isaiah. He wrote this about 700 years before Jesus. So this is what the Bible calls a prophecy. He is operating under the inspiration of the Holy Spirit, and he is telling us about Jesus. He doesn't use the name Jesus. He uses the pronoun he. He's talking about his servant. This is probably the most explicit prophecy about Jesus, 700 years before he would walk the earth, 700 years before he would go to the cross, that teaches us about the heart of Jesus, that teaches us about the heart of the good news of God in Jesus Christ. And here we see, if we want to ask the question,
is forgiveness appropriate? And if I conclude it might be appropriate, how do I engage forgiveness? Let's give you three steps here. One is we must understand the urgency of human sin. Verses five to six. We're going to focus, by the way, on verses four to six. If you open your Bible, look at four to six. There's a lot of verses. We're going to stay in that. It's kind of the center. It's like a center trio of all of Isaiah 52 and 53. First, we understand the urgency of human sin. Verses five to six. Second, we name the persons involved in your forgiveness situation. So I'm going to assume you have some kind of forgiveness situation. Maybe you've been a part of it before. Maybe it's alive right now. Rather, you need to extend forgiveness to someone and you're stuck. Or you need to receive forgiveness from someone or you need to receive forgiveness from God and you're stuck.
First, understand the urgency of human sin. Second, name the persons involved in your forgiveness situation. Verses four and five. And finally, as we conclude, know what biblical forgiveness is not. We began our service this evening. All we like sheep have gone astray. Let's start with understanding the urgency of human sin there in verse six. And we have turned everyone to his own way. Okay. It's very challenging because many of us aren't used to sheep. And if we are thinking of sheep, we find them cuddling, right? They're just they're just cozy. I mean, you just you hear the word sheep and you don't feel afraid. It's very challenging for a preacher. Very, very challenging. Because I need to find a way for you to hear sheep and feel terrified. All right.
A stray sheep. Oh, that little sheep lost its way. And immediately you're thinking of, you know, a bonnet and Bo Peep and courage and way or whatever. It's very unhelpful. Let's get to the second clause. To his own way. To her own way. To his own way. To her own way. Oh, from that comes the cruel statement. We make to someone that we
love. And then when they repeat the statement back to us, we can't believe we said it. But we know we did. Oh, to his own way, that's out of that comes the death of a small civilization when a family literally disappears after the divorce of a husband and wife. To his own way, that becomes the killing of nine Christians gathered for a Bible study by a white racist.
Oh, to his own way becomes a systematic genocide of over half a million Rwandan Tutsis by Rwandan Hutus in 1994. To his own way is the way of terror. Dr. Carmen and your American psychiatrist, not a believer, describes sin like this. Sin is implicitly aggressive. Sin is ruthless. It is willful, defiant and disloyal.
And of that, we're not enough. Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr., who did careful thinking about the Christian understanding of the cross and forgiveness. Dr. King said, not only is that true about sin, but sin is not contained. He wrote, quote, sin is a chain reaction of evil. As sin multiplies sin in a in a discerning spiral of destruction.
The way of our own way. Let's be very honest tonight. Let's just be very honest tonight. Anyway, it's the way of terror. Are you aware of that in your own heart? Things you've done or left undone. So there must be an even more powerful force to overcome the force of the spiral of destruction. And there is.
There's a counter force. There's a counter offensive to the offensive of sin, which is in every single human heart. Want me to understand this counter offensive? Is it a counter offensive of sacrifice and substitution that God has designed a way in which human beings that would be caught in this death spiral of destruction and terror and murder and all the realities that come with the with the lonesome power of sin? God designed a reality. He designed a system, a counter offensive to overcome the reality of sin and death. It can be called the Passover counter offensive. That in Exodus chapter 12, when the Jews were slaves in Egypt and God set out to rescue them, he warned Egypt, let my people go. And Pharaoh, the king of Egypt, refused to submit to what God said. So on a night now called Passover, an angel of death. And this is historical. This actually happened, passed through Egypt and killed every Egyptian firstborn son.
They had been warned. God gave them every opportunity to turn and they refused. But he made an escape for the Jewish people that they were to take a perfect lamb, bring that lamb into their home for four days. The lamb became a part of the household. And then they were to kill that perfect lamb and take the blood of that lamb and put it on a doorpost and mark their doorpost with it. And when the angel of death would see this blood, the blood of a perfect lamb, the angel of death would pass over that household. So the lamb was both a sacrifice
and a substitution for the firstborn son of that household. It doesn't say anything about this in Exodus 12, but. If you were that firstborn son, wouldn't you always love that lamb? When you go back and think about the four days you had with that lamb in your household,
and when you think, that lamb died in my place when others around me died? And the blood of that lamb protected my entire family from the reality of death? Oh, you'd think, I love that lamb. Had you named that lamb, you'd go back to its name over and over again. You'd thank God for that lamb by its name. You'd maybe name a child after that lamb. You'd do whatever you could to remember the lamb that actually died in your place.
You see, the same pattern, the sacrifice of a pure and healthy animal, and the substitution of an animal which occurs on the Day of Atonement in Leviticus chapter 16, wherein a bull would be killed, a goat would be taken, hands would be laid on that goat, the sins that it is would be put on that goat, it would be called the scapegoat, from which the phrase comes, and the goat would be sent outside the camp, bearing the sins of the people, that they might be free from their sin, that they might be free from death. To be free from sin, to free us from the death spiral of destruction, God had to create a way of life that was a counteroffensive to the way of death, and He does so by the sacrifice of a life, by substituting one life for another. Why sacrifice? Why the shedding of blood? Because the Bible tells us that blood displays the life of a creature.
Leviticus chapter 17, verse 11, the life of the flesh is in the blood. We need life amidst the death of sin. We need life against the death of those who have sinned against us. Only life can rescue us from a death spiral. The family of God, God said, if Adam and Eve disobeyed Him, they would die. Sin breeds death. Death is our judgment.
So there must be a death for our death, and there must be a life for our life, which is why every Sunday we proclaim in the Eucharist, Christ our Passover is sacrificed for us. Amen? Amen. It was not enough the blood of goats. It was not enough the blood of bulls. It was not enough the blood of a Passover lamb.
There was one who was sacrificed once for all. There was one whose blood is put on the doorpost of our lives. And those of us who love that lamb, who died in our place, who was substituted for us, oh, we love His name, oh, we cling to His name, oh, and we engage in that sin that we must be forgiven for, and oh, when we've been sinned against, even grievously sinned against,
that's the name. That's the one. That's how we live the cross. There must be a human death for a human life, a human substitute to take on all the sin of the human race. We read in Isaiah 53 that He was pierced for our sins, our transgressions. He was crushed for our sins. The Lord laid on Him as He did a scapegoat on the day of atonement, as He did in the Passover, the iniquity of us all.
God satisfies the need for sacrifice and substitution by doing this Himself. The Father gives the Son, and the Son offers Himself up on the cross. And there Jesus says, Father, forgive them, Luke chapter 23. There is no cost-free forgiveness. Christ, our Passover, is sacrificed for us, for you.
So name the persons in your forgiveness situation. Who is it that you need to forgive and you're stuck, in light perhaps of the sin that was committed against you, understandably stuck? Or name the sin that you need forgiven, that you need to be freed from. And who's the person that comes to mind first? Now it would be very understandable, particularly as I just shared that, that a proper name has come to you first.
But when we name the persons involved in a forgiveness need, we have to start with the servant Himself. Indeed, we go to He who has borne our griefs and carried our sorrows, verse 4. To think first of the one who has betrayed us, or even to think first of our own sin, would actually make the one who has betrayed us the principal character in our stories. To go first to the one who has sinned against you is to define one's life and one's story, one's need, by that one who has offended you, by that one who has sinned against you. When we go into a place of extending forgiveness, a place that takes great courage, a place that takes understanding of what has been given to you in Jesus and the forgiveness of your own sins, we always start with Jesus. When we extend forgiveness to someone who has sinned against us, we then, by forgiving
them, place them in their proper place in our story. When we forgive the sin that they have sinned against us, we take that sin and we remove it from our story, so that our story is not titled by one who has sinned against us. Our story is not titled by the sin against us. Our story has a very clear story. Our story has a very clear title. It's called Jesus and the cross of Jesus Christ.
Jesus gives you the agency in receiving forgiveness and in extending forgiveness to be free from your own sin or the sin of others against you. That's what he gives you. That's what he won for you on the cross. So I lived a story for several years, and I thought I had no agency to change the story.
My parents divorced in my late teens, and I was so angry. I was wracked with grief. I was I was insisting on never forgiving this grievous act against me. And in my insistence toward unforgiveness and in my embrace of what was in some ways righteous anger that became unrighteous over time, I lived somebody else's story. And I let somebody else determine my story, and I lost hold of the true story of my life. And I thought about certain people, and I obsessed about certain people, and I did things thinking about what that certain person would think about what I was doing. I gave them way too much power in my life, and I gave the sin of divorce that affected me way too much power in my life. And I didn't know the way out. I didn't know how to change the story. I didn't know how to get back to what I had lived before.
Until I understood the cross. Until I understood what had been sacrificed and substituted for me. And then when I forgave the sins against me, the people who had sinned against me were still part of my story, but they just had a chapter. And it didn't have the title.
And they weren't the whole novel. And Jesus took their place. So when you receive forgiveness or when you forgive, you invite Jesus to be the principal character of your story. I know it can feel very unsafe to extend forgiveness in some circumstances, and I wouldn't dare teach on this, lest I was compelled by the cross of Jesus Christ to do so, and that the Bible teaches it.
But I can assure you from a biblical worldview, it is far more unsafe to stay in unforgiveness and it is far safer for you and your soul and the story God wants to write in your life to forgive. So we forgive. We forgive as a sinner forgiving another for all we like sheep have gone astray. We forgive as we've been forgiven. It's not to say that the offense against us is equivalent to something that maybe we have done. We receive offenses against us and sins against us that we ourselves haven't necessarily committed. I'm not saying that. I'm simply saying we forgive as one sinner forgiving another sinner.
And then we need to know what forgiveness is not. First of all, forgiveness is not a kind of therapeutic transaction to relieve pressure in a relationship. And he sometimes those who sin against us can pressure us to then forgive them so that we can just move on with everything and we can forgive and we can forget.
And there can be pressure to kind of engage or enact in a kind of transactional thing where just say the word just just do something about it. That is not what forgiveness is. It is not just a matter of words. It's not just a matter of saying something or even saying the right thing. Forgiveness is rooted in the cross of Jesus Christ where we say because I was bought with a price and because you were bought with a price I refuse vengeance on you.
I refuse to take justice into my own hands. You don't refuse justice. Be assured God is a God of justice. And with the measure that has been meted out to you. So those who have met out of that measure will be judged the same. God will bring justice. God will bring vindication. God is a God of mercy and wrath. Be assured of that. But you're refusing to be God.
Which is the safest place you can put yourself in. You're saying. There was injustice. There was wrong. Think of Nadine Coyier. I'll never hold my mom again because of what you did. But God forgives you. And I forgive you. And she just got her story back.
She got her Jesus story back. Second. Forgiveness is not necessarily a commitment to trust again. It's important to get clear here. When you forgive someone. It's a particular grievous sins done against you. You're not saying you trust them again. You're not saying you'll be in regular relationship with them again.
Indeed in some cases it would be dangerous to re-engage in certain relationships. Where forgiveness must be given by you to another. It is one thing to forgive. It is another thing. To trust and rebuild trust. And those must be allowed to be distinct.
And often they are set one on top of the other. And so of course. One thinks I can't forgive. Because I could never trust. They're different. When you forgive. You're forgiving a past offense and sin against you. When you begin to work toward trust. And in some cases when there's forgiveness. You can work toward trust. In some cases.
You may not be able to. You must do so very carefully with great discernment and great counsel. You're moving toward the future. You may not be close to the person. Who grievously sinned against you ever again. Indeed you may need. Proper boundaries of that person that sinned against you.
But you have. The agency. And the dignity. And the love and power of Jesus Christ. To forgive them. So know what forgiveness is not. It's not a kind of therapeutic transaction. It's not a commitment to trust again. And finally. It's not optional. Now if you're not a follower of Jesus. And you're here. I can't hold that authority over you. But if you are a committed follower of Jesus. And you've committed yourself to live by the scriptures. Then. The authority of the scriptures does call us.
To enter into. The cross. To enter into. Jesus. And to enter into the life of forgiveness. Peter was working in this roof all over Jesus. And he says to him in Matthew chapter 18. Lord. How many times. Shall I forgive my brother or sister who sins against me. Be assured. He had a person in his story in mind. Perhaps one of his fellow disciples.
Up to seven times. And Jesus said. No. No. 77 times. Using a number of completeness. The number seven. Which was viewed as a number of completeness. To say. You never. Forgiving. Family of God. God has a story. That he's writing in your life.
Jesus. Is to be the principle. Character. Of your story. And the title of that story. Is with his wounds. We are healed. In the name of the father and the son and the Holy Spirit. Amen.
Holy Week 2024
11 sermons
- And Then There's Jesus...
Texts: Mark 11:1-11, Philippians 2:5-11, Mark 15:1-39
- The Faithful Friend
Texts: Exodus 12:1-14, Psalm 78:14-25, John 13:1-15, John 15:12-15
- God Makes a Way
Exodus 14 · Exodus 2:23-25 · Exodus 3:7-8 · John 14:6
- Easter Vigil, "The Fall"
Ephesians 6
- Easter Vigil, "Abraham's Sacrifice of Isaac"
Genesis 22:1-19
- Easter Vigil, "God's Presence in a Renewed Israel"
Isaiah 4:2 · Isaiah 28 · Isaiah 52:14
- Easter Vigil, "The Three Young Men in the Furnace"
Hebrews 11:33-38 · Matthew 5:8
- Easter Vigil, "Jonah and the Fish"
Jonah · Luke 23 · 2 Corinthians 4
- The Everyday Power of the Resurrection
Texts: Romans 6:1-14, Matthew 28:1-10
- The Everyday Power of the Resurrection
Texts: Romans 6:1-14, Matthew 28:1-10
